Part of a meta-list, generated from 130 best-of lists, by Shane Sherman.(Source)
In Search of Lost Time
#1, 1913
Ulysses
#2, 1922
Don Quixote
#3, 1605
One Hundred Years of Solitude
#4, 1967
The Great Gatsby
#5, 1925
Moby Dick
#6, 1851
War and Peace
#7, 1869
Hamlet
#8, 1601
The Odyssey
#9, 700 BC
Madame Bovary
#10, 1857
The Divine Comedy
#11, 1472
Lolita
#12, 1955
The Brothers Karamazov
#13, 1880
Crime and Punishment
#14, 1866
Wuthering Heights
#15, 1847
The Catcher in the Rye
#16, 1945
Pride and Prejudice
#17, 1813
The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
#18, 1884
Anna Karenina
#19, 1877
Alice's Adventures in Wonderland
#20, 1865
The Iliad
#21, 700 BC
To the Lighthouse
#22, 1927
Catch-22
#23, 1961
Heart of Darkness
#24, 1899
The Sound and the Fury
#25, 1929